As pet parents, we want the best for our dogs. The best food, the most comfortable collars, and toys that they’ll want to tear to shreds. There’s honestly nothing more disappointing than buying a stuffed squirrel for your furry friend, only to have them turn their nose up at it and return to chewing on your slippers.

To solve the challenge of finding something our pooches will get riled up over, we set out to find the best toys you can buy at Petco that will last a while and keep your dog’s interest piqued—and they’re all under $12, which makes them even better. By shuffling through reviews and relying on our own experience, we rounded up 10 toys that should perk up the