View photos

(Bloomberg) — Gilead Sciences Inc. analysts offered a broad range of views on the inadvertently leaked abstract that indicated the company’s remdesivir failed to provide a benefit in a placebo-controlled trial in Chinese patients with severe Covid-19.

Skeptical analysts included Baird’s Brian Skorney, who said the negative results “should be very sobering” given the lack of an improvement and argued that the result is “pretty close to a worst case scenario.” Others on Wall Street argued that investors should hold off on jumping to conclusions.

“The bottom line is that stating the trial flopped appears overly aggressive and premature, particularly in light of Gilead’s comments,” Piper Sandler analyst Tyler Van Buren said in a note. Gilead shares tumbled 8.5% before erasing some