While the broader market fumbled for a fourth-straight day, shares of Etsy, the ecommerce firm focused on vintage and handmade goods, tacked onto massive year-to-date gains that are on track to best all but one other stock in the S&P 500; here’s what Wall Street’s saying about the online craft-seller’s momentous rise.

The CEO of online marketplace Etsy, Chad Dickerson, stands with CFO Kristina Salen on the floor of … [+] the Nasdaq on the company’s first day of trading in April 2015.

Getty Images Key Facts

Shares of Etsy jumped more than 4% Tuesday, landing the stock at an all-time price high of roughly $197 per share and pushing