For United Methodists’ top court, 2024 is the new 2020

by | Mar 15, 2023 | Religion

(RNS) — An annual conference in the United States still can’t just up and leave the United Methodist Church.The United Methodist Judicial Council, the denomination’s top court, ruled again on that question in a decision released last week (March 7) as the church goes through a slow-moving split over the ordination and marriage of its LGBTQ members.
Three other decisions released by the court as it moves through its fall docket dealt with resolutions approved by annual and jurisdictional conferences — the UMC’s regional networks of churches and ministries — regarding LGBTQ inclusion.

RELATED: US annual conferences can’t just leave the United Methodist Church, rules top court

The Judicial Council ruled that a 2021 resolution by some Midwestern United Methodists, titled “Covenant to Build BeLoved Community,” is mostly “aspirational” and therefore does not conflict with the Book of Discipline, the United Methodist rulebook, which denies LGBTQ people ordination and forbids United Methodist clergy to perform same-sex weddings.
The resolution, approved by a special session of the Upper Midwest’s North Central Jurisdictional Conference, calls LGBTQ members “a gift to the church.” It also asks members of the jurisdiction not to pursue charges against clergy for officiating same-sex weddings or identifying as LGBTQ.
However, the court felt Michigan Bishop David Alan Bard went too far in accepting one line in the resolution — “We will not restrict God’s calling based solely on a candidate’s sexual orientation or gender identity” — which it deemed a “declaration of non-compliance.”
A copy of the Book of Discipline rests on a table during an oral hearing on May 22, 2018, in Evanston, Illinois. Photo by Kathleen Barry/UMNS
In another decision, the Judicial Council reversed a previous decision by Bishop Julius Trimble upholding a resolution passed last year by the Indiana Annual Conference called “A Commitment to Grace in The Indiana Conference” that had expressed support for clergy’s ability to choose which weddings they officiate. The resolution echoed the la …

Article Attribution | Read More at Article Source

Share This